ELSI Research Suggests Life Thrived on Earth 3.5 Billion Years Ago

3.5 billion years ago Earth hosted life, but was it barely surviving, or thriving? A new study carried out by a multi institutional team with leadership including the Earth-Life Science Institute (ELSI) of Tokyo Institute of Technology (Tokyo Tech) provides new answers to this question. Microbial metabolism is recorded in billions of years of sulfur isotope ratios that agree with this study's predictions, suggesting life throve in the ancient oceans. Using this data, scientists can more deeply link the geochemical record with cellular states and ecology.

Scientists want to know how long life has existed on Earth. If it has been around for almost as long as the planet, this suggests it is easy for life to originate and life should be common in the Universe. If it takes a long time to originate, this suggests there were very special conditions that had to occur. Dinosaurs, whose bones are presented in museums around the world, were preceded by billions of years by microbes. While microbes have left some physical evidence of their presence in the ancient geological record, they do not fossilize well, thus scientists use other methods for understanding whether life was present in the geological record.

Presently, the oldest evidence of microbial life on Earth comes to us in the form of stable isotopes. The chemical elements charted on the periodic are defined by the number of protons in their nuclei, for example, hydrogen atoms have one proton, helium atoms have two, carbon atoms contain six. In addition to protons, most atomic nuclei also contain neutrons, which are about as heavy as protons, but which don't bear an electric charge. Atoms which contain the same number of protons, but variable numbers of neutrons are known as isotopes. While many isotopes are radioactive and thus decay into other elements, some do not undergo such reactions; these are known as "stable" isotopes. For example, the stable isotopes of carbon include carbon 12 (written as ¹²C for short, with 6 protons and 6 neutrons) and carbon 13 (¹³C, with 6 protons and 7 neutrons).

All living things, including humans, "eat and excrete." That is to say, they take in food and expel waste. Microbes often eat simple compounds made available by the environment. For example, some are able to take in carbon dioxide (CO₂) as a carbon source to build their own cells. Naturally occurring CO₂ has a fairly constant ratio of ¹²C to ¹³C. However, ¹²CO₂ is about 2 % lighter than ¹³CO₂, so ¹²CO₂ molecules diffuse and react slightly faster, and thus the microbes themselves become "isotopically light," containing more ¹²C than ¹³C, and when they die and leave their remains in the fossil record, their stable isotopic signature remains, and is measurable. The isotopic composition, or "signature," of such processes can be very specific to the microbes that produce them.

Besides carbon there are other chemical elements essential for living things. For example, sulfur, with 16 protons, has three naturally abundant stable isotopes, ³²S (with 16 neutrons), ³³S (with 17 neutrons) and ³⁴S (with 18 neutrons). Sulfur isotope patterns left behind by microbes thus record the history of biological metabolism based on sulfur-containing compounds back to around 3.5 billion years ago. Hundreds of previous studies have examined wide variations in ancient and contemporary sulfur isotope ratios resulting from sulfate (a naturally occurring sulfur compound bonded to four oxygen atoms) metabolism. Many microbes are able to use sulfate as a fuel, and in the process excrete sulfide, another sulfur compound (Figure 1). The sulfide "waste" of ancient microbial metabolism is then stored in the geological record, and its isotope ratios can be measured by analyzing minerals such as the FeS₂ mineral pyrite shown in Figure 2.

This new study reveals a primary biological control step in microbial sulfur metabolism, and clarifies which cellular states lead to which types of sulfur isotope fractionation. This allows scientists to link metabolism to isotopes: by knowing how metabolism changes stable isotope ratios, scientists can predict the isotopic signature organisms should leave behind. This study provides some of the first information regarding how robustly ancient life was metabolizing. Microbial sulfate metabolism is recorded in over a three billion years of sulfur isotope ratios that are in line with this study's predictions, which suggest life was in fact thriving in the ancient oceans. This work opens up a new field of research, which ELSI Associate Professor Shawn McGlynn calls "evolutionary and isotopic enzymology." Using this type of data, scientists can now proceed to other elements, such as carbon and nitrogen, and more completely link the geochemical record with cellular states and ecology via an understanding of enzyme evolution and Earth history.

Figure 1.

Electron microscopy image of microbial cells which respire sulfate.
(Photo credit: Guy Perkins and Mark Ellisman, National Center for Microscopy and Imaging Research)

Figure 2.

Figure 2. Sulfide is formed by microbes which use sulfate in their energy metabolism, and this can be trapped for billions of years in iron sulfide minerals like those of the FeS₂ mineral pyrite in the photo. New research by Sim and colleagues shows the importance of an individual cellular enzyme in controlling the final mixture of sulfur isotopes in these minerals, in turn linking biochemistry, cell physiology, and the record of life on planet Earth. (Photo credit: Yuichiro Ueno, ELSI)

Reference

Authors :	Min Sub Sim1,2*, Hideaki Ogata3,4, Wolfgang Lubitz3, Jess F Adkins2, Alex L Sessions2, Victoria J Orphan2, Shawn E McGlynn2,5*
Title of original paper :	Role of APS reductase in biogeochemical sulfur isotope fractionation
Journal :	Nature Communications
DOI :	10.1038/s41467-018-07878-4
Affiliations :	1School of Earth and Environmental Sciences, Seoul National University, South Korea 2Division of Geological and Planetary Sciences, California Institute of Technology, USA 3Max Planck Institute for Chemical Energy Conversion, Germany 4Institute of Low Temperature Science, Hokkaido University, Japan 5Earth-Life Science Institute, Tokyo Institute of Technology, Japan

• Press release "ELSI Research Suggests Life Thrived on Earth 3.5 Billion Years Ago"
• Shawn McGlynn - Bridging disciplines and continents | Research Stories | Research
• Researcher Profile | Tokyo Tech STAR Search - McGlynn Shawn Shawn McGlynn
• Google Scholar - Shawn E. McGlynn
• ELSI
• Latest Research News